Comparison of Plaque Index (PI) calculation time between a Digital Dental Calculator (DDC) app and the manual method: a quasi-experimental study

Syaida Erma Putri, Satria Yandi, Ricky Amran, Netta Anggraini, Valendriyani Ningrum, Shih- Chieh Lee

Abstract


Introduction: Dental plaque is a soft biofilm that accumulates on the tooth surface and around the gingival margin. If not properly managed, it can lead to oral diseases such as gingivitis. The manual assessment of the Plaque Index (PI) has several limitations, including variability in the number of teeth examined, assessor subjectivity, and potential inaccuracy, particularly at low or high plaque levels. To overcome these challenges, a technology-based approach is needed to enhance standardization and consistency. This study aims to compare the calculation time of PI using a Digital Dental Calculator (DDC) app and the conventional manual method. Methods: A quasi-experimental study with a one-group posttest-only design was conducted among 70 dental students at Universitas Baiturrahmah who had completed the periodontics module and met inclusion and exclusion criteria. Participants performed PI calculations using both manual and digital methods under standardized conditions. The time required for each method was measured in seconds. Data were analyzed using descriptive statistics (mean ± SD) and the Mann–Whitney U test to compare calculation times between the two methods, with a significance level of p < 0.05. All analyses were conducted using IBM SPSS Statistics version 26.0 to ensure transparency and reproducibility. Results: The mean PI calculation time using the manual method was 178.74 seconds, while the digital DDC method required 143.97 seconds, showing a mean difference of 34.77 seconds. Statistical analysis revealed a highly significant difference between the two methods (p < 0.001), indicating that the DDC significantly reduced PI calculation time. Conclusion: The use of the Digital Dental Calculator (DDC) significantly shortened the time required to calculate the Plaque Index compared to the manual method. These findings highlight the potential of digital tools to improve efficiency, standardization, and accuracy in both clinical and educational dental settings.

Keywords


Plaque index, digital dental calculator app, calculation time, manual method

Full Text:

PDF

References


Husna, N., & Prasko, P. Effectiveness of dental health education using busy book media on the level of dental and oral health knowledge. Journal of Dental Health, 6(1), (2019). 51–55.

Pontoluli, ZG, Khoman, JA, & Wowor, VN Oral hygiene and gingivitis incidence in elementary school children. e-GiGi, 9 (1), (2021). 21-22.

Prihandini, WY, & Faizah, A. Gingival curettage treatment on maxillary right canine teeth. JIKG (Journal of Dental Science), 5 (1), (2022). 1–6.

Diah, D., Widodorini, T., & Nugraheni, NE Differences in the incidence of gingivitis between pre-pubertal and pubertal ages in Malang City. E- Prodenta Journal of Dentistry, 2(1), (2018). 108–115.

Erwin, E., Asmawati, A., & Sofyan, S. Differences of plaque index in examination with disclosing solution material and kesumba seeds (Bixa orellana). Jurnal Surya Medika (JSM), 6(2), (2021). 5–9.

Pratiwi, R., Nursyaputri, F., Indraswary, R., & Ratnawati, ID THE EFFECTIVENESS OF PHALERIA MACROCARPA’ S LEAF NANOEMULSION GEL ON STAPHYLOCOCCUS AUREUS BIOFILM THICKNESS (IN VITRO). Odonto: Dental Journal, 9, (2022). 69- 79.

Savitri, TM, Sembiring, LS, & Sugiaman, VK The effect of forest honey solution on the plaque and gingivitis index in adolescents. Makassar Dental Journal, 11 (2), (2022). 204–210. https://doi.org/10.35856/mdj.v11i2.596

Basuni, C., & Putri, DKT Description of oral hygiene index based on community education level in Guntung Ujung Village, Banjar Regency. Dentino Journal of Dentistry, 2(1), (2014). 18–23.

Sihaloho, N. Description of the Level of Independence of the Elderly in Fulfilling Daily Living Activities in the XIV Environment of Jalan Pembangunan Usu, Padang Bulan Village, MEDAN BARU District in 2021. Journal of Social Research, 1 (6), (2022). 435-442.

Asmawati, A., Sofyan, S., & Rasak, A. Dental and oral health survey in an effort to improve welfare in Lamotau village. Journal of Service and Dedication to the Indonesian Community, 1(1), (2023). 16–19.

Bahrun, S., Alifah, S., & Mulyono, S. Design and construction of a web-based marketing and sales survey information system. Journal of Transistor Electro and Informatics (TRANSISTOR EI), 2(2), (2017). 81-88.

La Rosa, GRM, Chapple, I., Polosa, R., & Pedullà, E. A scoping review of new technologies for dental plaque quantification: Benefits and limitations. Journal of Dentistry, 139, (2023). 1-2. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jdent.2023.104772

Adiyanta, FS Law and empirical research studies: The use of survey methods as an instrument for empirical legal research. Administrative Law and Governance Journal, 2 (4), (2019). 697-709.

Khurshid, Z. Digital dentistry: Transformation of oral health and dental education with technology. European Journal of Dentistry, 17(04), (2023). 943– 944.

Munro, C.L., Liang, Z., Emechebe, N., Chen, X., Cairns, P.L., Manani, P., Hamilton, L., Good, G., & Kip, K. Evaluation of an automated digital scoring system of dental plaque. American Dental Hygienists' Association, 94(2), (2020). 27–36.

Apriliyana, E., St, KBP, Pranata, IGAPD, & Maharani, NLPT Utilization of digital technology in the health sector in the 4.0 era to create a healthy generation of Indonesia. Proceedings of the Student Scientific Week (PILAR), 1, (2021). 61–67.

Nagarajappa, S., & Vyas, S. Smartphone-assisted oral health data recording—An Android-based software application development. Medicine and Pharmacy Reports, 94(3), (2021). 333-340.

Mariana, I., Fadriyanti, O., & Ningrum, V. Effectiveness of duration time to use the digital dental calculator application on DMFT index measurement. Journal of the Indonesian Dental Association, 7(1), (2024). 20–26.

Hastjarjo, TD Quasi-experimental design. Psychology Bulletin, 27(2), (2019). 187–203.

Oscar, B., & Sumirah, D. The effect of grooming on customer relations coordinator (CRC) on customer satisfaction at PT Astra International Tbk Toyota Sales Operation (Auto2000) Pasteur Bandung. Pro Mark, 9 (1), (2019). 3- 4.

Firmansyah, D. General sampling techniques in research methodology: Literature review. Scientific Journal of Holistic Education (JIPH), 1(2), (2022). 85–114. https://doi.org/10.55927/jiph.v1i2. 937

Moryka, AN, Ningrum, V., Lestari, C., & Batsukh, N. The use of digital dental calculator app as an OHI-S calculation tool: A cross-sectional study. Padj J Dent, 36(2), (2024). 163–170.

Fad'li, GA, Marsofiyati, M., & Suherdi, S. Implementation of digital archives for digital document storage. Manuhara Journal: Center for Management and Business Science Research, 1(4), (2023). 1–10.

Purba, NF, Annisa, FS, Syafitri, A., & Purba, SH Utilization of digital technology in public health services: A policy analysis review. Jurnal Kesehatan Unggul Gemilang, 8 (6), (2024). 42-43.

Hutasoit, SJ, Mariyanti, S., & Safitri, S. Analysis of the relationship between social attribution and altruism behavior in generation Z in DKI Jakarta. In Psychommunity National Seminar on Psychology Esa Unggul. (2023). 53-55

Fauzi, MR, Saimi, S., & Fathoni, F. Challenges and Solutions of Health Administration in the Digital Era (A Literature Review of Technology Implementation). AL-MIKRAJ Journal of Islamic Studies and Humanities (E-ISSN 2745-4584), 5(01), (2024). 1093- 1103. https://doi.org/10.37680/ almikraj.v5i01.6219




DOI: https://doi.org/10.24198/pjd.vol37no3.61740

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


 

Creative Commons License All publications by the Universitas Padjadjaran [e-ISSN: 2549-6212, p-ISSN: 1979-0201] are licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License .

Visitor Stat